Skip to main content

Dream Red Sox rotation for the 2027 MLB season

Get it done, Craig!
ByStephen Parello
Oct 6, 2026; San Diego, California, USA;  San Diego Padres pitcher Michael King (34) celebrates after the game against the Milwaukee Brewers in game three of the NLDS for the 2026 MLB Playoffs at Petco Park.  Mandatory Credit: Denis Poroy-Imagn Images
Oct 6, 2026; San Diego, California, USA; San Diego Padres pitcher Michael King (34) celebrates after the game against the Milwaukee Brewers in game three of the NLDS for the 2026 MLB Playoffs at Petco Park. Mandatory Credit: Denis Poroy-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Boston Red Sox's plan for the 2026 season was to overwhelm the opposition with a dominant starting rotation. That didn't quite come to fruition. The Red Sox's starters were certainly good, posting a 3.92 ERA that ranked eighth in the majors, but weren't quite dominant.

A big reason for that was the absence of Garrett Crochet for all but six starts. Having a Cy Young-caliber arm at the top would've taken Boston's unit from good to great this year, but alas, injuries are a part of life in baseball.

The good news is that most of the crew is still intact. The big question is whether Sonny Gray will come back or whether Craig Breslow will find a replacement who is on or above Gray's level. But if we're building a dream rotation, there's more work to be done beyond simply figuring out Gray's spot.

This rotation Craig Breslow could put together would be a Red Sox dream

No. 1 - Garrett Crochet

This is the easiest choice of them all. Crochet is a foundational piece for the Red Sox, and while Gray will likely finish in the top five in the 2026 AL Cy Young voting, a healthy Crochet might have stolen the award away. Here's to health in 2027.

No. 2 - Payton Tolle

Payton Tolle's ascension in 2026 was a sight for sore eyes. Not only did he put together one of the most dominant seasons a Red Sox rookie hurler has ever produced, but he endeared himself to the fans, not just in Boston, but around the league. Even more important, while he was good all season long, his strongest performance came down the stretch, with a 1.53 ERA in September,

Tolle is now a finalist for the American League Rookie of the Year. That could be just the start, and we could see him in the Cy Young conversation as early as 2027, while cementing himself as the staff co-ace.

No. 3 - Michael King

One of the key offseason needs is finding a right-handed starter to balance out the lefty-heavy rotation. There are three top options on the free agent market: Gray, Freddy Peralta and Michael King. Gray is the easy choice, but as we know, there was some friction between him and the club at the end, and it's not really wise to bet on a 37-year-old to repeat a career-best performance, especially when he was showing signs of decline over the previous two years.

Peralta's struggles with the Mets are still a red flag, despite his Rays magic. That leaves King as the best option. The 31-year-old is a proven top-of-the-rotation commodity, a dynamic postseason performer and a former New York Yankee. That last point doesn't really matter, except for the fact that it's always fun to twist the knife.

No. 4 - Ranger Suarez

Rangers Suarez might be miscast as an ace, but in this scenario he'd be one of the most overqualified No. 4 starters in the league. The crafty lefty knows how to get outs in the regular season, but like King, he's a playoff demon, owning a career postseason ERA of 1.48 over 42 2/3 innings. Unfortunately, the Red Sox weren't good enough in 2026 to give him the opportunity to continue dominating in October. With this dream rotation, Boston should give him that chance in 2027.

No. 5 - Jacob deGrom

You can call this Sonny Gray, part two. The Rangers were willing to deal deGrom at the trade deadline, but the two-time Cy Young winner invoked his no-trade clause to block a trade to the Atlanta Braves, citing a desire to win in Texas. The Rangers finished 80-82 and sat out October for the third straight season.

Now, there's an expectation that Texas will try to move the 38-year-old again, and maybe this time he'll be more receptive to a deal in his chase for a ring. deGrom is owed $37 million in 2027 and has a $20 million club option with no buyout for 2028. That's a hefty chunk of change, but there are some pathways to get a deal done.

If the Rangers throw in some cash, the Red Sox might be able to swallow that salary hit, especially for just one year. On top of that, Craig Breslow could convince the Rangers to take on Jarren Duran following the news that underperforming center fielder Evan Carter underwent hip labrum surgery and won't be ready for the start of 2027. Attach a prospect or two, and you could have a deal.

deGrom put up a 4.28 ERA in 2026, but that's not really indicative of how he performed. He posted a 30.1% strikeout rate, a 6.9% walk rate, and a 3.11 FIP. He's still a dominant presence, and if the Red Sox nab him while shedding Duran, it would be a massive win.

Add us as a preferred source on Google