The 2025 season was a roller coaster for the Boston Red Sox. At times, it felt like they wouldn’t even make the playoffs. A week later, it felt like a World Series-run was very much a possibility.
The reality was getting bounced in the Wild Card round. A short playoff run, sure, but valuable experience for the young guys.
The Red Sox's prospects had a wild year, as well, and need to be recognized. With that in mind, we’re going to make an all-prospect team.
The prospects need to have appeared in at least Single-A and can’t have played in a Major League game. That severely limits the pool as we lose players like Payton Tolle, Jhostynxon Garcia, and Connelly Early. They also need to still be in the organization as of October 1st (meaning prospects like Blaze Jordan are ineligible as well). In this section, we’ll discuss the starting nine and four bench players.
Boston Red Sox 2025 all-prospect team (position players)
Catcher - Johanfran Garcia
After returning from an ACL injury, Johanfran Garcia slashed .261/.328/.464 with seven doubles and 12 home runs between the FCL and High-A. The right-handed hitter drove in 41 runs, scored 37 more, and stole one base between the two levels. Garcia had three walk-offs with Greenville (two home runs), and not only played a surprising amount at the plate, but looked good doing so. The offseason might be spent getting into shape like his older brother did before the 2024 season.
1B - Nathan Hickey
Nathan Hickey looked solid at first base, seemingly transitioning to the position full-time. The left-handed hitter posted a .234 average (.733 OPS) with 23 doubles, two triples, and 17 home runs. He scored 45 runs, stole two bases, and led Worcester with 75 RBI (career-high). He needs to cut back on the strikeouts and find a bit more consistency, but still had a great season.
2B - Mikey Romero
Mikey Romero could’ve qualified for a few positions this season. The left-handed hitter didn’t seem to mind the moving around, as this was his healthiest (and most productive) season. Romero slashed .245/.300/.452 in 111 games between Double-A and Triple-A. He set career-highs in doubles (33), triples (4), home runs (17), RBI (76), runs scored (61), and stolen bases (5). Romero could stand to draw a few more walks (which he improved on this year) and limit strikeouts, but that power seems to be legitimate.
3B - Ahbram Liendo
Ahbram Liendo slashed .239/.323/.308 with 12 doubles, two triples, and four home runs. The right-handed hitter doesn’t feature much power, but he led the entire organization in stolen bases (42). Liendo isn’t just speedy, he’s one of the best defensive players in the system, making plays all over the infield.
SS - Franklin Arias
Franklin Arias plays an incredibly smooth shortstop. His offensive game was a bit erratic, but overall strong. The right-handed hitter slashed .278/.335/.388 with 27 doubles, one triple, and eight home runs between Single-A, High-A, and Double-A. He drove in 66 runs, scored 62 more, and stole 12 bases.
OF - Justin Gonzales
Justin Gonzales is 18, he’s listed at 6’4” (definitely taller, though), and he dominated in 2025. The right-handed hitter slashed .285/.367/.394 with 23 doubles, two triples, and four home runs between Single-A and High-A. Gonzales drove in 31 runs, scored 50 more, and stole 12 bases. He showed an advanced eye, drawing a good amount of walks while limiting strikeouts. Despite the low home run total, there’s terrifying power in his bat. He’ll be on this list again next season.
OF - Nelly Taylor
Nelly Taylor struggled with the bat at times this season, but the glove was always spectacular. The left-handed hitter slashed .216/.355/.349 with 24 doubles, three triples, and seven home runs. He drove in 41 runs, scored 62 more, and stole 29 bases. Taylor has elite speed and defense and is a proven leader.
OF - Allan Castro
Allan Castro had a nice bounce-back season, slashing .268/.353/.400 with 20 doubles, two triples, and seven home runs. The switch-hitter posted 37 RBI, 43 runs, and 15 steals. Castro doesn’t excel at one specific aspect of the game, but he does a great job of finding ways to impact in all aspects.
DH - Starlyn Nunez
Starlyn Nunez has defensive potential, making plenty of flashy plays. However, the errors piled up on him this season. The switch-hitter was a major spark plug for Salem, though. Nunez slashed .249/.306/.407 with 24 doubles, eight triples, eight home runs, 52 RBI, 54 runs, and 21 stolen bases.
Bench - Gerardo Rodriguez (C)
Gerardo Rodriguez showcased unexpected power in Single-A and is a fantastic defensive catcher. If the bat is legitimate, the Red Sox have a serious catching prospect on their hands.
Bench - Marvin Alcantara (INF)
Marvin Alcantara is a good defender who can play multiple positions. He didn’t hit for power, but he limited strikeouts in 2025 and had some clutch hits. Mentioned as a leader, which gives him some bonus points.
Bench - Max Ferguson (UTIL)
Max Ferguson is an underrated defender who can play multiple positions, swiped 34 bags, and posted a decent OBP despite a low batting average. He’s a fantastic plug-and-play guy who deserves a bit more recognition despite not being a big-name prospect.
Bench - Miguel Bleis (OF)
Miguel Bleis has all the tools to be a superstar; it’s just a matter of whether he’ll put them all together at the same time. He has elite speed, a fantastic glove, and great power. Don’t give up on him.