How Red Sox compare to 1998 New York Yankees, 2001 Seattle Mariners

BOSTON, MA – SEPTEMBER 08: Brock Holt #12 of the Boston Red Sox takes batting practice before the game against the Tampa Bay Rays at Fenway Park on September 8, 2017 in Boston, Massachusetts. (Photo by Omar Rawlings/Getty Images)

Bench

1998 New York Yankees
Pos	Name	PA	HR	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS+
UT	Tim Raines	382	5	0.290	0.395	0.383	107
C	Joe Girardi	279	3	0.276	0.317	0.386	85
IF	Luis Sojo	153	0	0.231	0.25	0.265	37
DH	Chili Davis	118	3	0.291	0.373	0.447	116
LF	Ricky Ledee	87	1	0.241	0.299	0.392	81
UT	Homer Bush	78	1	0.38	0.421	0.465	134
UT	Shane Spencer	73	10	0.373	0.411	0.91	236
2001 Seattle Mariners
Pos	Name	PA	HR	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS+
UT	Mark McLemore	487	5	0.286	0.384	0.406	115
LF	Stan Javier	323	4	0.292	0.375	0.391	109
C	Tom Lampkin	231	5	0.225	0.309	0.348	78
UT	Ed Sprague	107	2	0.298	0.374	0.436	119
UT	Charles Gipson	72	0	0.219	0.282	0.313	61
UT	Jay Buhner	53	2	0.222	0.34	0.4	100
2018 Boston Red Sox
Pos	Name	PA	HR	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS+
UT	Brock Holt	284	3	0.268	0.349	0.372	96
C	Christian Vazquez	218	3	0.213	0.249	0.300	48
UT	Blake Swihart	125	1	0.226	0.288	0.304	61
UT	Steve Pearce	87	6	0.310	0.425	0.634	181
UT	Eduardo Nunez	411	7	0.26	0.285	0.374	76
IF	Tzu-Wei Lin	49	0	0.182	0.265	0.227	36

It’s difficult to decide who counts for the bench on these teams. The Yankees, for example, received massive contributions down the stretch from Homer Bush and Shane Spencer, but both of these players had fewer plate appearances than five other members of the Yankees bench and thus could justifiably have been left off had I cut at the five bench players with the most playing time. I decided to include every player that was not listed in the lineup above with 50 or more plate appearances (Tzu-Wei Lin sneaks in at 49 because Boston hasn’t yet played a full slate).

The Red Sox bench clearly leaves something to be desired outside of Steve Pearce. Pearce has mashed at a rate that no one could’ve foreseen in his short time in Boston. Given how bad the team was against lefties early this season, his presence has been indispensable. However, everyone besides Brock Holt and Pearce has been below replacement level. That is not ideal.

The ’98 Yankees and ’01 Mariners, on the other hand, had very deep benches. In the Bomber’s case, the bench was led by Joe Girardi (a surely familiar name to Yankees fans still), HOFer Tim Raines, old friend Chili Davis, and absolutely insane performances by Homer Bush and Shane Spencer. Spencer, in particular, hit 10 homers in 27 games. Everyone besides Luis Sojo was above replacement level and at least a couple of these guys could’ve had everyday jobs on many first division teams. That’s championship level depth.

Tha ’01 Mariners bench surely seems far more anonymous to most baseball fans. The only name that jumps out is Jay Buhner and he was almost a non-factor on the season. However, Mark McLemore and Stan Javier were worth 3.5 bWAR and 2.8 bWAR off the bench respectively. Each of those totals is way more than the entire Red Sox bench combined.

Bench

Schedule