The 2026 season didn't end well for the Boston Red Sox, and not just because they lost to their bitter rival New York Yankees in the Wild Card round for the second straight year. Some Red Sox players were vocal in their opposition to the way the front office and management have made in-game decisions.
Sonny Gray was angry about being pulled from Wild Card Game 2 in the fifth inning, earlier than he or most Sox fans watching would've liked. Manager Chad Tracy pulled Payton Tolle in a similar moment the game before. Willson Contreras after the Wild Card elimination critiqued Boston's over-reliance on analytics with some brutally honest statements.
"It’s not enough when you have talent, or you have data, or you have computers telling you what to do, because this is baseball," Contreras said. "The data is here to help us, but at the end of the day, you’re going to need experience and veteran guys to win games. There’s a lot of stuff that I would like to say, but I'll stay (with) that."
Many past players have had gripes with the Red Sox's use of analytics and disregard of the "eye test." As a veteran, team leader and main offensive contributor, Boston should take Contreras' comments seriously.
Willson Contreras talked out post-Wild Card analytics comments with Red Sox management
Apparently, it has. After Contreras was spotted at the World Series rooting for his brother, he told Peter Abraham of The Boston Globe that he spoke with Tracy and Craig Breslow in the days after his analytics comments, and the conversation was constructive (subscription required).
“I feel good about things, for sure. One hundred percent,” Contreras said, via Abraham. “Things are in a good place.”
The Red Sox need buy-in from their players if they want to be successful, and being on the same page as Contreras is a step in the right direction. As a clubhouse leader, Contreras should be able to defend Boston's hitting philosophy and approach to himself and other players, if necessary. The system should also work for the players, and Contreras' comments suggest it did not.
Contreras also said the Red Sox need to bring in more veteran talent and estabilshed players to improve for next season. If he's truly in agreement with Breslow and Tracy about that, it could bode well for Boston's expected offseason additions. Contreras led the team in home runs this past season, but the Red Sox obviously needed more help in the power department — maybe Breslow will provide.
Breslow has become notorious for his rough communication style since he took over in Boston. The quick meeting between him, Tracy and Contreras could be a sign of things changing for the better in the front office.
Add us as a preferred source on Google