Most reporters and fans didn't see a reunion coming between the Boston Red Sox and Sonny Gray. The veteran's relationship with Red Sox management didn't end on the best note and there were rumors that he might want to play for a team closer to his home in Nashville, Tennessee.
Any chance of a potential reunion died on November 18 when Gray signed a two-year, $55 million deal. Gray has an opt-out after the first year. The righty spent two seasons with the Twins from 2022-23, and posted arguably the best campaign of his career in the latter season, when he finished second in the American League Cy Young Award race.
In his introductory press conference via Zoom with Minnesota reporters, Gray explained that there didn't seem to be any real interest from the Red Sox in regards to a reunion.
“As far as a reunion, it never really came up. I think the times we did have any type of conversations, it never really got close, it felt like, which is completely OK," Gray said via Chris Cotillo of MassLive (subscription required).
Red Sox should've made a bigger effort to reunite with Sonny Gray before Twins signing
After seeing how well Gray fit in Boston's rotation last season, it should've made a bigger and better effort to bring him back for at least another year. Gray was one of the best right-handed arms available on the free agent market before his signing. Some of the other options — Michael King, for example — would warrant longer, pricier deals than Boston may be willing to enter.
Gray reportedly considered retirement at some points during the 2026 season, going as far as saying he'd retire "in a heartbeat" if his family wanted (subscription required). Shortly after the end of the 2026 season, he told reporters that he'd reevaluated his stance and would play a few more seasons to hunt for a championship, which would be the first in his career.
The Red Sox still have work to do before they can count themselves into the upcoming World Series conversation, but Boston seems closer to a title than the Twins as the two teams are currently constructed. Had the Red Sox approached Gray with a slightly smaller offer, he might've accepted for another couple chances at the postseason.
There are some risks associated with signing Gray, however, which might've pushed the Red Sox in a different direction. Gray is entering his age-37 season, and a multi-year commitment to a pitcher of that age is a bold move, especially at Gray's price. His strikeout rate has also steadily dropped over the last two seasons and his walk percentage spiked in 2026.
Still, the Red Sox saw what Gray can bring to their rotation, and the complete lack of interest from the front office is surprising. Boston will have a lot of work to do to find a worthy right-handed replacement in its rotation, because none of its internal options will cut it.
