Skip to main content

Red Sox sign high-upside reliever Yankees failed to unlock the last 2 seasons

Another former Yankees pitcher for the Red Sox pitching lab.
ByBrandon Glick
New York Yankees pitcher Michael Arias.
New York Yankees pitcher Michael Arias. | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

When the Boston Red Sox signed Jake Bauers last week, one understated footnote stuck out to me: The first baseman represented yet another former New York Yankees player to join the other side of baseball's oldest rivalry.

The list of such ship-jumpers in recent years is long, but it includes notable figures such as Garrett Whitlock, Rob Refsnyder, Aroldis Chapman, Jahmai Jones, and Mickey Gasper. There have always been defectors and the occasional one-off trade between these two teams, but it feels like we're in the midst of a full-blown epidemic right now.

Well, you can add another name to the pile now, as Craig Breslow is up to his old tricks again. The Red Sox have reportedly signed Michael Arias to a minor-league deal with a non-roster invite (NRI) to spring training, poaching another pitcher from the Yankees' farm system.

Red Sox's fun, no-risk bet on Michael Arias has a hidden lockout benefit

There was a lot of hype among the Bronx faithful when they first acquired Arias, a converted shortstop who throws really hard and climbed a bunch of top-prospect lists while in the Cubs' system. The Yankees completed his full-time conversion to relief pitching to try and maximize his raw stuff (and mitigate his poor control), but they never quite figured out the perfect solution for the right-hander.

He climbed as high as Triple-A with the Cubs, but the Yankees have stashed him in Double-A over the past couple of years. His strikeout rates of 30.2% (2025) and 24.2% (2026) at the level remain tantalizing, though walk rates well above 10% have kept him from becoming a shutdown reliever. The Red Sox will have to help Arias hone his command, since a pitcher with three 50+ grade pitches should never be working with chase and whiff rates in the bottom quartile among all Double-A pitchers, a feat the righty just accomplished in 2026.

Having just turned 25, Arias is still a young arm with a ton of projectability. As a minor-league signing, there's no pressure on him to have all of this figured out by Opening Day. The non-roster part of his contract is especially important in that regard, since he'll be eligible to play minor-league ball while the lockout is going on (assuming it extends that long). If he looks really good during that time, he could make a push to join the big-league roster down the stretch in 2027.

But that's just me getting ahead of myself. The most important thing about this signing is that the Red Sox continue to add upside to their system. The pitching lab has had tons of success with reclamation projects in the past, few of whom have possessed Arias' raw tools.

Add us as a preferred source on Google