Skip to main content

Red Sox insiders give mixed messages about possibility of Sonny Gray reunion before Twins signing

The door is officially closed.
ByBrandon Glick
Boston Red Sox pitcher Sonny Gray.
Boston Red Sox pitcher Sonny Gray. | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

To say that the Boston Red Sox and Sonny Gray ended the first year of their partnership on a sour note would be an understatement. The veteran right-hander made some pointed comments about Chad Tracy's decision to remove him from Game 2 of the Wild Card Series against the New York Yankees, effectively stating that he felt as though the team didn't trust him to handle big moments.

At that point, it felt like a near-certainty that Gray was a goner. The Red Sox's fully-outfitted starting rotation, plus a wealth of pitchers returning from injury, made a reunion a little redundant. Considering that he was also expected to earn a sizable payday in free agency, the frigid ending to the season really just seemed to serve as the precursor to his eventual departure.

Of course, that's exactly what happened this week, as Gray agreed to a two-year, $55 million deal to return to the Minnesota Twins, where he nearly won a Cy Young award in 2023. It's almost certainly the last contract he'll sign, as the 37-year-old has openly mulled retirement in the past.

However, this may not have been as inevitable an outcome as we previously thought; Gray and the Red Sox reportedly made amends following that playoff elimination. It got to the point that both sides were interested in potentially extending their union according to CBS Sports' Julian McWilliams.

Red Sox's interest in a Sonny Gray reunion never got them close to a deal

With a contract that will now pay him $27.5 million per season over a two-year period, it's not hard to see why the Red Sox ultimately fell short in bringing Gray back. The team already has $63.5 million AAV wrapped up in three starters (Garrett Crochet, Ranger Suarez, and Brayan Bello), and adding Gray's salary to that total would have ballooned the payroll without leaving much room for more offensive upgrades.

Then again, Gray was Tracy's most dependable starter for long stretches of the 2026 season, ultimately leading the team in innings pitched (169) and starter ERA (2.72). Replacing that production with in-house talent is far easier said than done, which is why it wouldn't be surprising to see the team chase a different (and cheaper) veteran arm prior to the lockout.

For what it's worth, that search isn't being started from scratch. Gray admitted that a reunion with the Red Sox "never really came up" after signing with the Twins, acknowledging that the two sides made peace and ultimately went their separate ways. There was clearly interest in him returning to Boston, but those talks apparently didn't go beyond the preliminary stage.

Now, the goal is replacing what he brough to the team in 2026, from his steadiness on the mound to his leadership in the clubhouse.

Add us as a preferred source on Google