For an organization that's been around as long as the Boston Red Sox have been around, it's not surprising that there have been some bad trades. No team exists for 126 years without a few missteps along the way, but the Red Sox have made some of the worst deals in MLB history.
Two trades stand out in the minds of baseball historians. The first is the trade that sent Babe Ruth to the New York Yankees for $100,000 (the equivalent of $1.786 million in October 2026, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics). He had helped the Red Sox win three World Series in his time in Boston, and after they dealt him, the Curse of the Bambino kept Boston from winning another for 86 years. The other worst deal came 100 years and two months later.
Not wanting to extend Mookie Betts for a fair market price, and not wanting to lose him for nothing in free agency, the Red Sox traded the 2018 MVP to the Los Angeles Dodgers for a three-player package. The Red Sox got a former top-100 prospect in Alex Verdugo, a then-current top-100 prospect in Jeter Downs and catching prospect Connor Wong.
Red Sox DFAing Connor Wong officially stamps Mookie Betts trade as the worst in franchise history
Every single player the Red Sox got back in the Mookie Betts trade is now gone…
— Jordan Moore (@iJordanMoore) November 18, 2026
• Jeter Downs: In Japan
• Alex Verdugo: Free agent
• Connor Wong: DFA'd
Meanwhile, Mookie has won 3 World Series titles in LA. Boston has won 2 playoff series total since. Worst trade ever. pic.twitter.com/FCNoKcQPuh
Verdugo's Red Sox career was never quite what Red Sox fans hoped for from the promising young outfielder, and he was eventually traded to the Yankees after just four seasons in Boston. Jeter Downs never panned out in MLB. He appeared in 14 games with Boston in 2023 before being designated for assignment and claimed by the Washington Nationals. He is currently playing in the Japanese minor leagues. Connor Wong ended up the longest-tenured of the three, but he was also DFA'd, marking an unceremonious end to the trade for the Red Sox.
The three players the Red Sox got for Betts ended up returning 11.7 bWAR in the seven seasons after the trade. Betts cleared that in his first three seasons in L.A. and has racked up 36.4 bWAR for them. The Red Sox have not made the World Series since trading the former MVP. The Dodgers have won three in that time.
Both trades have worked out terribly for the Red Sox, but every passing day, the Betts trade looks more and more like the worst trade in Red Sox history. The top prospect in the deal did nothing, the top player in the deal lasted four seasons with the team and never reached his potential, and the final remaining player was DFA'd, never becoming a full-time starter. At least Red Sox Nation can finally put this trade in the rearview mirror.
