3 former Red Sox players that will make Boston regret letting them go in 2024
The Red Sox lost a fair few players this offseason without making up for the deficiencies.
The Boston Red Sox lost a few players through free agency and trades this offseason, as most teams do.
But most other teams try to fill the holes left by previous players who leave in the winter. The 2024 Red Sox? Not so much.
The Red Sox will be missing some fan favorites, and others, on its Opening Day roster, and they would have been better with them than without. Some of the players Boston let go will make the front office regret letting them walk this upcoming season. Some are entering contract years, some have gone to incredible teams, and others are simply impact players that leave a gaping hole in a roster in their absence.
The Red Sox's lack of spending in recent seasons is counterintuitive. Sure, the front office is saving money now by not spending to keep hold of some of its lost players, but not signing new and relevant talent will make it harder for them to recruit more talent to come to the Red Sox in the future. And it feels like that time has already come.
3 former Red Sox players that will make Boston regret letting them go in 2024
Alex Verdugo (Yankees)
It's been rumored that the Red Sox were happy to get rid of Alex Verdugo, so much so that they engaged in a rare trade with the rival New York Yankees to swap him for a package of arms. Verdugo, a good defender with a fine bat when he's in his stride, just joined a much better team than the one the Red Sox are fielding.
Verdugo is entering a contract year, which means he's likely to be stepping up all facets of his game to earn his highest possible salary in 2025. And he's set up to be able to do that well in the same batting order as sluggers Juan Soto and Aaron Judge. He'll also be playing in an outfield with much easier dimensions than Fenway Park. Sure, Yankee Stadium's left-center field goes back nearly 400 feet, but playing in right at Fenway will train any outfielder to defend at a high caliber.
Verdugo's offensive production declined each year he was with the Red Sox — the 27-year-old finished the 2023 season hitting .264/.324/.421. Verdugo was a streaky hitter in 2023, but anything can happen in a contract year. Maybe some hitting advice from Soto and Judge boosts Dugie's production.
Swapping Verdugo for Tyler O'Neill could be considered an even trade if O'Neill returns to form, but the Red Sox are likely going to miss Verdugo's offensive production in his slot in the batting order.
Justin Turner (Free Agent)
Justin Turner took hold of fan-favorite status seemingly as soon as he put on the Red Sox uniform — his beard gives Sox fans flashbacks to the 2013 World Series winning squad. Turner took on a leadership role as one of the more experienced veterans in the clubhouse and his offensive production remained consistent all season.
Turner's bat has been reliable throughout his career, and his right-handed power is desperately needed by Boston. He hit .276/.345/.455 in a Red Sox uniform and played serviceable defense for the team, though he spent most of his time as the designated hitter, a position that probably suits him best at 39 years of age.
Turner opted out of his contract and chose not to return to Boston in 2025, likely because he saw the direction the team was taking or, we'd like to think, he figured he had the opportunity to earn more money after a successful campaign. Despite being unsigned at the time of publication, a reunion between Turner and the Red Sox doesn't seem likely to the chagrin of Sox fans everywhere. Yup, they don't feel like spending money, so why would they on an aging asset? But consistency is the key to Turner's success — wherever he signs, that team will be lucky to have him.
James Paxton (Dodgers)
The Red Sox were eyeing a potential reunion with James Paxton, but the Dodgers burned them, yet again. Boston needs a left-handed starter in the rotation and Paxton was one of the few options left on the market.
Paxton hasn't had as much success in the latter years of his career as he had in the beginning, but it should be noted that he's made significantly fewer starts as he's aged due to injuries. Paxton logged a 4.50 ERA and 101 strikeouts in 2023 after pitching 96 innings with the Red Sox. But he was on the mend and started to look better.
Paxton became a free agent after his lone year with the Red Sox, and though a reunion may have been out of the question from the jump, money always talks. The Dodgers reportedly gave him $12 million. The Red Sox wouldn't have been crazy to offer a larger one-year deal or even a two-year pact. Then again, it was rumored that Paxton wanted to play on the West Coast, closer to his offseason home in Washington, and the superteam that is the Dodgers would be a great target location for anyone at this point.
Paxton's 2023 season turned out to be slightly worse than average, but in Boston's current rotation, Paxton's left-handedness and years of starting pitching experience could have been valuable in helping the younger arms develop. Also, the presence of an actual starter rather than a bunch of converted relievers would've been nice, too.