Skip to main content

Pete Alonso's Silver Slugger win shows why Red Sox should have major free agency regret

Think about it ... what's the price of Contreras and Bauers?
ByKatie Manganelli
Baltimore Orioles v. New York Yankees
Baltimore Orioles v. New York Yankees | Rob Tringali/GettyImages

Willson Contreras had an incredible debut season with the Boston Red Sox — the best season of his career, to be exact. The catcher-turned-first baseman hit .275/.386/.516 with 12 doubles, three triples, 27 home runs and 81 RBI over 130 games. Contreras was one of three qualified hitters to finish the season with an OPS over .900, alongside Yordan Alvarez and Pete Crow-Armstrong.

Contreras' standout offensive performance earned him consideration for the American League Louisville Slugger Silver Slugger Award at first base. Unfortunately, he did not win. New division rival Pete Alonso did. For the second year in a row, FanSided partnered with Louisville Slugger to announce the finalists and winners of the 2026 Silver Slugger awards.

The Red Sox and Baltimore Orioles were some of the strongest competitors for Alonso's services last offseason. The latter team eventually emerged victorious, and Alonso is a brutal and dangerous rival to have in the already-grueling AL East.

There were rumors over the offseason that Boston didn't pursue Alonso with all its might due to his age and skillset — he seems almost certain to become a full-time designated hitter later in his career, which the Red Sox haven't been willing to roster in recent years. Those rumors were later refuted by Jared Carrabis, who claims an unnamed team source said the Red Sox were "very close" to landing Alonso.

Pete Alonso beating Willson Contreras in Silver Slugger race shows Red Sox should've gone all-in last offseason

Contreras hit and got on base more consistently than Alonso did, but Alonso won out in the power category (and also had a major advantage in games played). He finished the season with 24 doubles and 48 home runs, the second-most in MLB this season. Sox fans have to wonder if Alonso would've hit even more home runs if he played half his games at Fenway Park.

There are more upsides to Alonso than just his slugging ability. He's been remarkably durable in his career and he's never played fewer than 152 games in a season (besides in the pandemic-shortened 2020 season). Alonso has also grown into a better defender at first base with zero outs above average and defensive runs saved, which doesn't sound like much, but he usually finishes in the negatives. Like Contreras, Alonso is a passionate player and he could've been a leader in Boston.

Contreras is arguably one of the best additions of Craig Breslow's career as chief baseball officer. His career-best numbers in Boston were unexpected, and he earned MVP votes for them. Red Sox fans are thrilled to see what Contreras will bring next year.

Still, the Red Sox need more power. And when you need power and Alonso is available, you should pay him whatever he asks. The Orioles got it right.

Add us as a preferred source on Google