Dustin May was atrociously bad for the Boston Red Sox last year. Sox fans probably didn't need a reminder of that, but it's important to put that on the record before trying to analyze his new contract.
A free agent once again after slightly rehabilitating his value with the St. Louis Cardinals and reigning champion Milwaukee Brewers, May was firmly in line to improve on the one-year, $12.5 million deal he got on the open market last year. Even that was seen as a bit steep following his ugly tenure in Boston, but pitchers who can throw hard and have top-prospect pedigree are usually pretty effective at convincing at least one team to make ill-advised investments in them.
That being said, the heist that May just pulled on the Chicago White Sox is going to be talked about for a while; he's set to earn $52.5 million over the next three years, good for an AAV of $17.5 million.
BREAKING: Free-agent pitcher Dustin May and the Chicago White Sox are in agreement on a three-year contract worth just north of $50 million, according to sources familiar with the deal.
— Robert Murray (@ByRobertMurray) November 17, 2026
Dustin May's newest contract will have Red Sox fans shaking their heads in disbelief
In defense of the White Sox, there is some justification to this deal. May was pretty good for the Cardinals prior to the 2026 trade deadline (3.15 FIP), and a $17 million salary is the going rate for solid starters these days. There's also probably some lockout-related fears baked into the contract, as the Pale Hose might be preparing for a salary floor or some similar mechanism that forces Jerry Reinsdorf to actually invest in his product on the field.
Still, this is a lot of money to invest in a pitcher who has an ugly injury history and hasn't been very good on the rare occasion that he does make all his scheduled starts.
At least the right-hander has made progress on that first point recently, tossing 130+ innings in consecutive seasons after failing to break the 100 frame mark in each of his first six years in the big leagues. It's still a risk to trust a guy with his injury history to be a mid-rotation starter for the next three campaigns, but that's what the White Sox are betting on.
The second point remains the bigger concern for May, who was middling with the Dodgers prior to last year's trade deadline (4.85 ERA), downright putrid with the Red Sox after it (5.39 FIP, -0.1 fWAR), and barely usable for the Brewers during their playoff run (5.73 ERA in 11 postseason innings). He's still got a big fastball and some intriguing raw stuff, but at some point, teams have to accept that he just hasn't been able to translate it into actual production.
The White Sox appear to believe they're the organization capable of unlocking May. As the Red Sox could tell them, that's a job that's easier said than done.
