Grady Little leaves Pedro Martinez in too long
I racked my brain, went through each awful letdown in Red Sox history, and yet I kept going back to this one. We’ve talked about different moments throughout the lifetime of the franchise but this one is the most egregious in recent memory to me. For me, leaving Pedro Martinez in for the eighth inning in the 2003 ALCS was a horrible decision, and the one I’d change in a heartbeat.
Obviously selling Ruth is a head-scratcher that even if you spoke to the ghost of Frazee, he couldn’t justify. Giving Sale an extension a year before it was necessary, especially after having injury woes in the postseason, I’m not so sure of. Firing the most beloved manager in Red Sox history and covering his name in mud, bad job by you Boston. And then we have someone that can relate to my selection. McNamara mismanaged the Sox in 86 and crippled their chances at winning, similar to Grady Little in 2003.
More from Red Sox News
- Red Sox Nation deserves far more from Fenway Sports Group
- Bizarre trade deadline comes back to haunt Red Sox after Nathan Eovaldi departure
- Red Sox’ Moneyball-style offseason continues with Corey Kluber contract
- Rich Hill’s Red Sox departure puts him within striking distance of unique MLB record
- Red Sox offseason takes another nasty hit with Nathan Eovaldi departure
As Drew pointed out, McNamara managed to not lose, whereas Little managed to win. He knew this would possibly be his final game with the Red Sox and he made sure his strongest weapon had the ball in his hand. Problem is, Pedro was clearly ready to be done with the game as he gave his trademark salute to the heavens as he walked off after the bottom of the seventh.
That should’ve been all that Little needed to see, but instead, the manager trotted a seemingly spent Martinez out for the eighth. The Boston fireballer would only get one out in that inning while giving up three runs, allowing the Yankees to tie the score. Fast-forward to the bottom of eleventh where Aaron Boone hits the game-winning homer. A position the team wouldn’t have been in had Grady just went to the bullpen for the eighth.
Could the pen have given the game away just as easily? Absolutely! But they were never even given the chance to fight for the win. By leaving Pedro in for that inning even though it was clear to anyone that has ever seen him pitch that he was done, Little gave the Yankees that win. The pain of 2003 would be rectified a year later as Martinez would be a key component in the Red Sox defeating the Yankees in another ALCS Game 7. Had Pedro been pulled after the seventh in 2003 though, we may have been celebrating after 85 years instead of 86.
-BSI Site Expert, Brendan Mizgala