Option D – 3x All-Star, 1x MVP, 3 Playoff Appearances, 1 Championship Titles
Player Comparison: Rick Porcello
The final option paints a picture of both a player and a team that reached the zenith of the sport but was unable to sustain success. The candle that burns twice as bright burns half as long.
Rick Porcello‘s tenure in Boston conjures mixed feelings from fans. He did win a Cy Young in 2016, albeit controversially. Not that Porcello wasn’t good in 2016, but the only major statistical pitching categories he led the league in that year were wins, and K/BB ratio. Meanwhile, the second-place finalist, Justin Verlander, bested him in nearly every other category including 1st place Cy Young votes.
More from Red Sox News
- Bizarre trade deadline comes back to haunt Red Sox after Nathan Eovaldi departure
- Red Sox’ Moneyball-style offseason continues with Corey Kluber contract
- Rich Hill’s Red Sox departure puts him within striking distance of unique MLB record
- Red Sox offseason takes another nasty hit with Nathan Eovaldi departure
- Why Red Sox fans should be rooting for Carlos Correa’s Mets deal to go through
Porcello nabbed the award but wasn’t able to replicate his 2016 performance in his final three seasons in Boston. He went from leading the league in wins in 2016 to leading in losses in 2017.
2018 was a bounce back to form for him en route to a World Series title, but the team made it clear they weren’t interested in extending his contract.
He became a free agent after the 2019 season and would eventually sign with the Mets. Unlike the other players on this list, Porcello is still active and very well could win more individual awards and championships. While I wish him all the best, it seems his best years are behind him and the Mets certainly aren’t the club to be at if you want to win a title.
Verdict: There’s only one correct choice of the options above and that’s option A. Sure it was probably frustrating for Williams to never win it all in his storied career, but he’s also the only player from the above list that is enshrined in the Hall of Fame and has his number retired (although I hope 33 gets added to that list one day). Heroes get remembered, but legends never die.