Personal Accolades
Bagwell:
- National League Rookie of the Year 1991
- National League Most Valuable Player 1994
- 4-time All-Star (1994, 1996, 1997 and 1999)
- Gold Glove Award 1994
- 3-time Silver Slugger (1994, 1997 and 1999)
- National League RBI Leader 1994
- Daryl Kile Good Guy Award 1994
- 6-time Astros Most Valuable Player
Andersen:
- Held no awards
Team & Major League Baseball Records
Bagwell went on to set many team and major league baseball records.
Bagwell as a player:
- Holds the MLB record for 6 straight seasons of 100 BB, 100 runs, 30 HR and 100 RBI
- 2-time 30-30 club member
- MLB Record – only 1st baseman with 400 HR’s and 200 SB
- Team Record – hit 13 home runs in one month 06/94
- MLB Record – doubles in one game – four
- MLB Record – walks in one game – six
- World Series appearance 2005
Andersen as a player:
- 2-time World Series appearance 1983 and 1993
- Held no team records or set MLB records
Seeing a trend? I think you get the picture here. No other player did as much for the Astros franchise as Bagwell did. Wouldn’t be hard to find a reliever who was able to accomplish what Andersen did.