Aug 12, 2013; Bronx, NY, USA; Fans hold signs referring to New York Yankees right fielder Ichiro Suzuki (not pictured) during the first inning against the Los Angeles Angels at Yankee Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Debby Wong-USA TODAY Sports

Tell Me How You Really Feel. What Makes Yankee and Red Sox Fans Tick.

Jul 20, 2013; Boston, MA, USA; A fan makes a catch on a foul ball during the ninth inning in a game between the Boston Red Sox and New York Yankees at Fenway Park. Mandatory Credit: Bob DeChiara-USA TODAY Sports

Boston vs. New York. Red Sox vs. Yankees. Charming Fenway Park vs. imposing Yankee Stadium. Baseball cogniscenti Bostonians vs. baseball entitlement royalty New Yorkers.  It’s a no-brainer to say Red Sox and Yankee fans don’t like one another not much if anything about their respective opposing teams. But what about all the other things they like? What makes Yankee and Red Sox fans tick?

The fascinating folks at have recently published a great post called “What Your Team Says About You“. It reveals insights into not only Red Sox and Yankee fans but fans of another classic rivalry, the Giants and the Dodgers. Without going into all of the awesome InfoGraphs and data in the blog, these revelations below should be enough to whet your appetite.

  • Red Sox fans…
    • Are the most socially minded of the four fan bases.
    • They have the greatest focus on local and cultural traditions (hurray for St. Paddy’s Day).
    • Edge out the competition in their love of beef and video gaming (a very different Saturday night than Giants fans apparently are having).
    • Are more than 5 times more likely to put on their Bronie gear and watch My Little Pony than an average Internet user.
  • Yankees fans…
    • Have an unusual Interest Graph composition.  While they have a relatively low number of topics in which they are highly interested, the volume of topics they cover is well above normal levels for a cohort of this size.  This is likely a function of the general appeal of the Yankees to fans that are more geographically and demographically diverse.
    • They lead the pack in their interest in exotic dancers and nude recreation.

My two favorite graphs are below. Click the link above and enjoy. All I can say in closing is My Little Pony? Really?

Screen Shot 2013-09-13 at 11.05.22 PM

Next Red Sox Game View full schedule »
Wednesday, Sep 33 Sep7:05at New York YankeesBuy Tickets

Tags: Boston Red Sox Fans

  • Rick M

    The real rivalry is Boston, NY and Philadelphia and it dates back well
    over 300 years. It is more than baseball: It is economics, politics, education, social status,prestige and a myriad of other items wrapped up on a competitive ball that has been with us since the 17th century. Baseball is just one
    aspect of it.

    • Earl Nash

      Rick, I thoroughly enjoy your comments and wish you would consider joining the team here at BSI. Hanging around past 60, allows one to collect a lot of information that allows the writer to provide a historical context for articles. Knowledge is fine, but Wisdom is better.
      “What is the price of experience?”

      • stephenepeterson

        That would be our one and only Rick McNair Earl! :)

        • Earl Nash

          Emily LaTella: “Oh…never miiiiiiind…”

          • Rick M

            Senior moment, Earl? Not that I would know ANYTHING about that!

          • Earl Nash

            More like a Senior day! LOL ! I am so glad you joined the staff and look forward to your posts, just like a dog with a full bladder…

  • Earl Nash

    How to explain why Red Sox fans prefer Ms. Upton to winning?