Aug 10, 2013; Kansas City, MO, USA; Boston Red Sox center fielder Jacoby Ellsbury (2) drives in a run in the fourth inning against the Kansas City Royals at Kauffman Stadium. Mandatory Credit: John Rieger-USA TODAY Sports

Who’s In The Hunt For Jacoby Ellsbury?


As expected, Jacoby Ellsbury is having a solid contract season. With just 33 games left to go in the 2013 campaign, a healthy Ells has once again emerged as a dominant force for the Red Sox. He is an elite center fielder this season, leading the majors in stolen bases (46) and in the top 10 in average (.299, 3rd), on base percentage (.358, 4th), slugging (.426, 6th) and OPS (.783, 7th).

August 20, 2013; San Francisco, CA, USA; Boston Red Sox center fielder Jacoby Ellsbury (2) steals second base against San Francisco Giants second baseman Marco Scutaro (19, left) during the first inning at AT

He is 11th among center fielders at .990, which is a misleading statistic since he gets to so many more balls that may go as an error than other center fielders. In short, he’s very, very marketable.

Boston needs him as their center fielder long term. There’s no other center fielder on the market that posses his killer combination of speed, true lead off sensibilities and an intangible that no one talks about. Ellsbury is a professional baseball player who keeps his mouth shut and lets his playing do the talking. He’s a great teammate. Just ask around the club house. And now he’s in jeopardy of going to another ball club in the offseason.

So who’s in the hunt and who’s out? As provided by Fangraphs, here’s a rundown of who won’t be looking for Ellsbury’s services in 2014 and beyond.

Angels: All set with Mike Trout and Peter Bourjos.
Pirates: Set with Andrew McCutchen.
Blue Jays: Colby Rasmus has improved a lot this season aside from his strike outs, 132 to date, sixth in the AL. The Blue Jays may waive Melky Cabrera and move Rasmus to left field.
Brewers: The Brewers are fine with Carlos Gomez.
Orioles: Adam Jones is a lock.
Diamondbacks: Jason Kubel will likely not be back in Arizona, but with Gerardo ParraAdam Eaton and Cody Ross in the fold, they’ll have more than enough to go around.
Detroit: Austin Jackson will stay in center field for the Tigers.
Rockies: Dexter Fowler will be their man.
While not necessarily enamored with their respective center fielders, the Braves (B.J. Upton), Dodgers (Matt Kemp) and Padres (Cameron Maybin) are stuck with them.
Indians: All set with Michael Bourn.
Rays: Fine with with Desmond Jennings.
St. Louis: Jon Jay is a defensive liability but the Cardinals will likely stay with him.

That leaves 16 teams, who may or may not be in the hunt. The most likely candidates are:

Red Sox: Sure they want to sign him but I still say that his 2010 falling out with the organization, Scott Boras as his agent and the Sox wanting to get Jackie Bradley Jr. in centerfield are working against them.
Royals: 27-year old rookie David Lough has been a pleasant surprise but is definitely a downgrade from Ellsbury. Ellsbury could be instrumental in becoming a key cog in what is becoming a very good baseball machine as Boston’s recent series in KC proved.
Yankees: Curtis Granderson is a free agent and the Yankees have always taken special glee in sticking it to the Sox whenever the opportunity presents itself. This steal would be particularly delicious for the Bombers. Every night Brian Cashman wakes up in a frothy sweat after dreaming about this.
Philadelphia: Ben Revere is a pretty good center fielder but can easily transition to right should GM Ruben Amaro decide to pull the trigger after a sleepy and non-productive 2013 off-season.
Giants: San Francisco has a ton of cash potentially rolling off their books this season which would make them prime candidates to offer a fat wad and a lot of years to Ellsbury, a native west coaster.
Rangers: Alex Rios will be back in the folder but with both Nelson Cruz and David Murphy heading for free agency, they’re going to have a big gap that needs to be filled if they want to remain competitive.
Nationals: This a real on the bubble pick. Jayson Werth is good player but he gets hurt a lot. Denard Span is on for four years but has been so bad the Nats may ditch him if Ellsbury was serious about moving further down I-95.

The Cubs (no outfield obligations), Reds (seriously in need), Mets (Juan Lagaras and Marlon Bird can make room if the Mets decide they may be ready to compete again), As (Ellsbury replacing Coco Crisp?) and Mariners (almost home state boy comes home) are all teams that would likely draw up an offer at the drop of a hat but may not want or be able to part with enough cash to let them sleep at night nor make Ellsbury happy enough after being on playoff or near-playoff contenders throughout his career.

An even more in depth analysis of Ellsbury’s options can be found here at Fangraphs.

What do you think? Will Ellsbury be back in a Boston uniform in 2014?

Will Jacoby Ellsbury be back in a Boston Uniform in 2014?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Tags: Boston Red Sox Jacoby Ellsbury

  • Rick M.

    The Red Sox have already set the financial bar for Ellsbury thanks to their contract with Carl Crawford. As for any personal preference no one really knows, as very few snippets come from Camp Ellsbury, except the usual platitudes of a player approaching the big payday.

    If it is all about the money that will limit potential suitors, but I would lean heavily towards the Yankees. The park is built for someone with his OF speed and the lineup is always steady when in one piece.

    IMO I would make his signing a priority.

    • John Fahrer

      The Yankees do seem pretty committed to getting under that LTT and are trying to do that while retaining Cano. They’re more likely to bring Granderson back since he’s a buy-low gamble at this point.

      Cherington will set his price for Ellsbury to take it or leave it. Chances are somebody else will outbid the offer, likely the Rangers, Cubs, or Mariners.

      Leadoff/CF is a grueling job and they paid Bradley a nice-sized bonus to be the successor. Rotate the stock and keep the pipeline going.

      • Rick M.

        I NEVER rule out NY. The Cubs situation is interesting based on how much ire Ellsbury still retains from the botched 2010 season and how responsible he holds Theo.

        If organizational stability and performance are in the picture that could narrow down possibilities.

        I’m all for signing him.

  • John Fahrer

    Have a feeling the Mariners will want to bring Ells closer to home. Possibly the Rangers. Cubs are a dark horse, but they seem to be avoiding long-term deals while purging the ones they already have.