September 30, 2012; Baltimore, MD, USA; Baltimore Orioles center fielder Adam Jones (10) is out at second base as Boston Red Sox shortstop Jose Iglesias (58) starts the double play in the first inning at Oriole Park at Camden Yards. Mandatory Credit: Joy R. Absalon-USA TODAY Sports

Jose Iglesias, No-Hit Shortstops, and Value

Since the advent of Nomar Garciaparra, Derek Jeter, Alex Rodriguez completely redefining the shortstop position, the all-glove, no-hit shortstop has been a sort of dying breed in today’s game. Where once shortstops were expected to be the backbone of the defense and nothing more, the game’s most prestigious position has certainly become relied on for offensive production as well. Even if it’s not quite the numbers put up by the Nomar, Jeter, A-Rod trifecta a decade ago.

That leads us to Jose Iglesias. Iglesias was the major international signing for the Sox in 2009, inking a record $6.25 million bonus with the club. While fielding has never been a problem, Iglesias has famously struggled to hit throughout his professional career, hitting an absolutely anemic .135/.210/.203 during his abbreviated Major League stints in 2011 and ’12.  His minor league numbers aren’t much better either, having hit just .264/.313/.314 with onlytwo (2!) home runs over a 1000 Minor League plate appearances. While Iglesias (deservedly) gets a ton of flak for his overmatched bat, people overlook the fact that even with below average offense, he can still have plenty of value.

In today’s game, the prime example of the no-hit, all-glove shortstop is Seattle’s Brendan Ryan. Ryan’s offense is a little less laughable than Iglesias’, as he is (wait for it) a career .244 hitter. Granted, Ryan has played in one of the more hostile hitting environments the past two seasons (Safeco Field); however, no one is confusing Ryan’s bat as anything more than passable.

Yet,  when looking at the annual WAR leaderboards (using Baseball-Reference’s version), Ryan has traditionally been ranked higher than many of his peers, including Derek Jeter and Jimmy Rollins last year. I know not everyone agrees with WAR and I don’t always agree with it either (for example, I’d still take Jeter over Ryan last season). However, I feel it is a much better measurement of value than traditional, “triple crown” stats (AVG/HR/RBI)  because it can determine a player’s entire body of work (hitting, baserunning, and defense) and make one number out of it.

People too often overlook the impact that defense has on ballgames because it doesn’t show up in the box scores (errors are a flawed stat for a multitude of reasons; inability to measure range being one of them). A diving play that prevents two runs from scoring; a laser throw from the outfield grass that keeps the leadoff hitter from reaching base; a heads-up play that stops the opposition from tying up the ballgame. All of these plays have value. Although it might not be quite as obvious as an RBI single or home run, a run is a run, no matter how you chalk it up.

Last year, Ryan posted a 3.5 WAR, a number that made him the 63rd most valuable player in baseball while hitting just .194. While that number was driven by a probably unsustainable league leading 3.6 dWAR (WAR comprised from just defensive contributions) and 27 defensive runs saved  (numbers of runs above or below average a fielder was), Ryan provided legitimate value without even hitting his weight. Additionally, albeit last year’s career highs may be a bit extreme, Ryan has a long track record of posting at least 2 WAR and 2.6 dWAR annually since he began receiving steady playing time in 2009. When 2 WAR represents a league average starter, and Ryan is surpassing that without practically any offense whatsoever, it further proves that there is more value in defense than most would usually expect.

Iglesias, by all measures (defensive metrics or the simple “eye” test), is in the same sort of league as Ryan defensively; whether it be because of his extraordinary first-step quickness, unparalleled range, or strong arm, Iglesias is the definition of an elite defender. It is not farfetched that he could produce similar WAR totals to Ryan if just given the opportunity.

If Iglesias’ bat breaks out this year (he is batting a robust .583 this season), then the Red Sox shouldn’t have any doubt as to who is their shortstop of the future. But maybe this year represents more of the same, and Iglesias’ bat will simply lag behind his glove. Count me in the latter, as I still think thousands of at-bats with poor results trump 12 at-bats with good results. Even without competent hitting, Iglesias can still have plenty of value on the diamond, and (I think) possibly more than a healthy Stephen Drew. Just don’t give up on him if he is hitting .230 in June; he’s more valuable than you think.

Next Red Sox Game View full schedule »
Saturday, Aug 2323 Aug1:35Seattle MarinersBuy Tickets

Tags: Brendan Ryan Defense Jose Iglesias

  • JJ Tardy

    Inglesias may profile as a plus defender but he is no Brendan Ryan. You have good glove men at SS, elite level SS’s and then another level where Ryan is by himself. How else does one explain Ryan’s 89 Defensive Runs Saved since he became a starter half way into 2009 to 2012.

    The next closest SS’s in that time period – The Elite – are:
    Alexei Rameriz with 46 DRS from 2009 – 2012
    Troy Tulo with 39 DRS from 2009 – 2012
    Yunel Escobar with 39 DRS from 2009 – 2012
    Elvis Andrus with 24 DRS from 2009 – 2012
    JJ Hardy with 22 DRS from 2009 – 2012

    Ryan has more than double the the 2nd best defensive SS in MLB.

    Even though this article is about how much value a player can provide playing strong defense from the SS position, suggesting or comparing an unproven AAA player to Ryan’s defense is pie in the sky stuff. This is like projecting a hot AAA hitter to put up Pujols type offensive numbers. I think a more realistic forecast would be an Elvis Andrus level of defense which without league average offensive production for a SS is probably not good enough to sustain a starting position.

    • Aidan Flynn

      JJ, thanks for the comment. While perhaps it is too extreme to compare him to Ryan right now, Iglesias is that kind of talent defensively. I know this is a subjective comment but I have seen/heard plenty of scouts say Iglesias will immediately be the best defender at SS once he establishes himself. Even just looking at his DRS in his limited PT (yes, I know SSS and the noise that comes with defensive metrics) but DRS has him at 8 runs saved in about 260 innings and 37 over a whole year. While that 37 DRS is unsustainable, it goes to show the kind of defender he is.
      As for your second comment, defense in the minors translates much, much, much better to the majors than hitting. Projecting a defender’s transition to the bigs is entirely different than comparing a hittter’s transition. It’s apples to oranges. The field is the same dimension and the balls are coming off the bat practically the same (for the most part). The fastballs, curves, changes, control, command are vastly superior. It’s not the same thing.
      As I said before, maybe he’s not “Ryan” good, but he still can be a valuable player if he’s the second best defensive SS in the league.